Teachers Get Guidance On How to Relay the Lessons of Sept. 11

July 7th, 2008

From the beginning, there was purpose behind forced schooling, purpose which had nothing to do with what parents, kids, or communities wanted. Instead, this grand purpose was forged out of what a highly centralized corporate economy and system of finance bent on internationalizing itself was thought to need; that, and what a strong, centralized political state needed, too. School was looked upon from the first decade of the twentieth century as a branch of industry and a tool of governance.

—John Taylor Gatto, The Underground History of American Education

Besides that nonsense 9/11 Commission Report, look at what teachers are being told to bake into the curriculum:

“Tell the story in the classroom about those who suffered losses simply unimaginable, but also about what came out of that loss that was absolutely amazing,” said Kean, a former teacher. “As part of 9/11, you have to tell that story.”

Fetishization of the victims. To be followed, I wonder, by a rousing session of the two minutes hate?

What possible use could students—who are barely able to read or find their own country on a map—have for topics like operation NORTHWOODS, what happened at NORAD that morning, the collapse of the buildings, the flying circus, on and on and all the rest?

None of that.

Sit down, peck at your GPS tracking unit, eat your breakfast stick and shut up. Oh yeah, write a paper about the victims.

No thanks.

I’ll teach my son about 9/11 at the dining room table.

Via: Star Ledger:

As chairman of the national 9/11 commission, former Gov. Thomas Kean has gone before the president, Congress and other powerful dignitaries with lessons of Sept. 11.

Yesterday, Kean spoke to an ar guably more-influential audience when he shared many of those same lessons with educators crafting a curriculum for teaching New Jersey’s children about the attacks.

“You have an enormous responsibility,” Kean told the group gathered at Liberty Science Center in Jersey City. “How to teach this terrible event and get across these things to our children, you are vested with that incredible responsibility. But if I have faith in anything, I have faith in teachers.”

The setting was a conference kicking off a yearlong effort to develop curriculum and resources for teachers faced with a dual challenge of teaching the history and context of the terrorist attacks in communities that witnessed them.

And with about 100 educators in attendance yesterday, it was clear the hurdles don’t stop there. There are rising demands on teachers throughout the year, scant resources in textbooks and elsewhere and even the timing difficulty of an niversaries that come only days after schools open.

“We need to be dealing with this in totality … more than a simple commemoration,” said Robert Barnshaw, a Gloucester Township teacher. “And in the pattern of the year, Sept. 11 is probably not the best time to be doing that.”

To hear Kean and others speak, Sept. 11 could easily be its own course, although most agreed it’s a topic better infused across different subjects and even into nurses’ and counselors’ offices.

“It’s an event that’s absolutely unique in the history of this coun try and needs to be treated as such,” said Kean.

The former governor’s national commission in 2004 penned a scathing report on the lead-up to the attacks, with widespread blame meted out for security lapses and policy failures. While mincing few words yesterday in sharing those lessons with teachers, Kean also implored them to tell students about the courage and action that arose from the attacks, from the heroism on Flight 93 to the activism of survivors’ families.

“Tell the story in the classroom about those who suffered losses simply unimaginable, but also about what came out of that loss that was absolutely amazing,” said Kean, a former teacher. “As part of 9/11, you have to tell that story.”

2 Responses to “Teachers Get Guidance On How to Relay the Lessons of Sept. 11”

  1. Peregrino says:

    How do you teach kids that they are participating in the end of the world as we know it? If they are not learning emergency survival strategies and skills their time is being wasted. But 90% of classroom time is wasted time, and always has been. School from K-12 has always been primarily child care, not education. I’m laughing at career teachers now; soon they will be teaching that two plus two equals five or face losing their jobs for corrupting the minds of youth with dangerous, unpatriotic ideas, otherwise known as the truth.

  2. Mike Lorenz says:

    I teach at a private high school, so I don’t have as much official pressure to teach certain things. The general atmospere, however,is rather conservative – both religiously and socially. I’m neither of those things. I take a good deal of pleasure in exposing kids to ideas and viewpoints that they’re not used to. I’ve used “Fahrenheit 911”, “The End of Suburbia”, and “A People’s History of the United States” by Howard Zinn as the basis for projects about Peak Oil, the war in Iraq, and 1st ammendment rights.
    @ Peregrino, I’ve pondered your sentiment many times in the past few years. It seems like there is such a fundamental disconnect between what these kids are learning in the classroom and what they’re going need to know in the future. The vast majority of them simply can’t wrap their heads around the idea of a world that doesn’t involve them going off to party at college for 4 or 5 years, and then getting some fabulous job with their Business Management degree. That, or they’re convinced that they’re going to get rich being a fashion designer or a pro athlete. It’s quite maddening.
    @ Kevin, Awesome choice on the Gatto quote. Reading “An Underground History…” was ground shaking for me. It put a lot of things I had long suspected in context and had a huge impact on how I teach.
    – Mike Lorenz

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.